Saturday, April 14, 2012

2. Churches should have less paid staff

This is a continuation of a couple of previous posts.  The first is here.

I think that churches seek to have too many paid staff.  I fear that we're turning ministry into a professional venture and that we're pushing the layman out of the ministry of the word.  I don't understand the reasoning for our model of ministry and I think it's unbiblical.

I don't understand why we should pay people to tell others about Jesus.  I don't understand why we're
professionalising being a Christian.  I do understand that we need ministers who are paid.  But we have to understand that we don't pay them to do a job.  We pay them so that they don't have to have a job.  We seek out men who are leaders in the church community and we pay them so that theyhave time for the local church that they wouldn't have otherwise.  These men should be leading a team of other men who do work so that together the church is administered, the gospel is preached and the community is looked after.  I don't really see why, in your average small church, we should have more than one paid minister. I don't see why themain ministry of that minister has to be preaching.  This idea has some basis in the Bible, but that doen't make it biblical.  If you have capable lay preachers then let them preach.  If a minister's a talented preacher then by all means prach every week, but if not then do what you're good at and let others do what they're good at.  I've seen too many great ministers who are wondeful at looking after and encouraging Christians struggle each week to preach to think that this works.

I think that too many ministers and assistant ministers and youth ministers and children's workers only really serve to professionalise something that is all of our responsibility.  They create in groups and out groups. 

I don't like the idea that the leadership of the church is the responsibility of a few and that there is so much opportunity for pew sitting from church members. 

I think that the sharing of the gospel is everyone's responsibility.  I hear ministers and church leaders lament that their parishioners aren't telling people about Jesus, but they're not sharing the responsibility of teaching within the Christian community with their parishioners. 

I think we should have a hard look at the way we do church.  I think that we talk big about spurring one another on, encouraging one another and sharing the load, but then we hire men and women to do what we should all be sharing together.

There's a place for paid ministry.  But do we really need so many?

8 comments:

  1. I agree that ministers are paid so that they don't have to have a job. That is why they are paid a stipend and not a salary.
    Unfortunately many churches assume that the minister is the employee of the church and that the lay leadership team forms a type of board of directors with powers of hiring and firing and supervising the minister's activities. That model is enshrined in the constitutions of some churches.
    I think that there is a need in many churches for some sound biblical teaching on leadership.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, good point. I think that the parishioners in lots of churches need to be corrected as to what the role of the minister is. He isn't an employee, and neither is he a sole authority. He's the guy that the congregation puts themselves under and the guy that they willingly submit to. Both the congregation and the minister need to take this relationship seriously. I know that I struggle with it at times.

      Delete
  2. Yes, it can be an interesting and often unhelpful mess of expectations.

    It is very easy to go to home church and have no-one paid and to all share the reponsibilities. Although home churches can get challenging at times!

    The big problem is the humans!!

    ReplyDelete
  3. A good first step would be to stop referring to 'the minister'. Every time we say that it reinforces the assumption that 'the minister' is the person who does the ministry, or the 'ministry team' does it, or whatever. At that point, so much for "every member ministry".

    Church leaders are pastors - those who lead the people of God toward the promised land and watch the flock for danger, etc. The whole congregation needs to own the title 'minister' and then act like it.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Just my hobby horse. I think it goes rather well with the point you are making here.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I too agree ... but I wonder at what level we have become complicity in the 'professionalisation' of 'ministry' and that we have "enabled ourselves" to become merely cheerleaders from the sidelines of church ministry....

    But there is an underlying assumption which possibly needs correction ... that 'church' is the primary vehicle for gospel ministry ... it is the body of believers who meet together for mutual encouragement, teaching, community and fellowship, the question I ask myself ... was it ever meant to be the vehicle for 'gospel ministry' ... it should be a believers oasis in the midst of living the gospel in the world and through our lives ... for me, school, soccer, socialising, Scouts and family ... not the place / time / gathering in which we do anything other than cultivate true encouragement, admonishment and fellowship towards each other so that we grow in love with God and so we are further spurred to sharing a gospel life and the gospel message in our communities... the 'church' community is one from which we are sent out into the world ...
    I think of the apostles in Acts when they delegated the roles and responsibilities to the deacons of the administration of the church and the needs of its members so that the apostles could continue preaching the gospel ... to those not yet saved ... not only those who had believed the gospel ... What is more, just after Stephen is appointed a deacon for the care of the widows and needy in the church he is arrested and martyred for preaching the gospel ... I think we have not only 'professionalised' but have highly 'specialised' roles and gifting to an unbiblical level. We have followed the world in this respect.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Another great post Graham.

    We've been wondering about the number of people in ministry lately. There are so many MTSers around. Sometimes I just want to say 'go get a job, and evangelise there, and let the students do it at uni'. I don't know. We keep getting asked for money. We can't possibly support all the people we know well and are in paid ministry.

    I also find myself wondering whether Christians go into ministry because secular work is hard and tiring and has no tangible 'eternal' benefit. But this is sort of the definition of work right? I don't know.

    Just thinking out loud and digressing, don't take me too seriously.

    ReplyDelete