Showing posts with label Science. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Science. Show all posts

Monday, August 30, 2010

Emergence

I've been away on a conference and then have been organising a move. So I'm sorry for my lack of posting (not sure who I'm apologising to... the net? Anyway...)

I have lifted these excerpts directly from another blog. All the details of where it comes from are given there. But the topic is emergence. I love emergence, I think it's such a fantastic concept, it's really important in my area of physics, as well as many other fields. It's great. Anyway, it's also a bit heavy, so I hope the ideas will blow you away as much as they did me:

This account of the dynamical theory of chaos leads to a metaphysical picture of a world with an open future, in which the laws of physics are emergent-downward approximations to a more subtle and supple reality and in which there is downward causation through information input as well as upward causation through energy input. Such a metaphysical picture can accommodate both human and divine agency.
Subatomic particles are not only not “more real” than a bacterial cell, they also have no greater privileged share in determining the nature of reality.
.... If apparently open behavior is associated with underlying apparently deterministic equations, which is to be taken to have the greater ontological seriousness—the behavior or the equations? Which is the approximation and which is the reality?
....epistemology and ontology are intimately connected. One can see how natural this view is for a scientist by considering the early history of quantum theory. Heisenberg’s famous discussion of thought experiments, such as the gamma-ray microscope, dealt with what can be measured. It was an epistemological analysis. Yet for the majority of physicists it led to ontological conclusions. They interpret the uncertainty principle as not being merely a principle of ignorance (as Bohm, for example, would interpret it) but as a principle of genuine indeterminacy. In an analogous way, it seems to me to be a coherent possibility to interpret the undoubted unpredictability of so much of physical process as indicating that process to be ontologically open.....
d’Espagnat [who discussed the philosophical implications of quantum theory] does not go all the way with Kant. He insists that independent reality is veiled rather than inaccessible; it is elusive rather than absolutely unknowable.
I am driven to greater metaphysical boldness .... I believe that his cautious invocation of veiledness is, at the least, not inconsistent with the kind of openness about the nature of reality that I am trying to explore.
.... such a world of intertwined order and novelty is just that which might be expected as the creation of a God both faithful and loving, who will endow God’s world with the twin gifts of reliability and freedom....
The correct lower-level description can only provide an envelope of possibility within which top-down causation will find its scope for realization. 
..... God’s interaction with God’s own world can be expected to respect its freedom (including our own). God’s acts will be veiled within the unpredictability of complex process. They may be discernible by faith, but they will not be demonstrable by experiment.

Tuesday, July 6, 2010

Why Physicists are Christians

Did you know that there are more Christian physicists than there are Christian ministers?

Neither did I... That's nonsense.

But there are a lot of Christian physicists. More than any other discipline, scientific or otherwise I think. I've always encouraged my extraordinarily intelligent and gifted wife to do a PhD in arts (English Literature or Cultural Studies) because a. She's a great writer, and b. There are very few - almost no, in fact - Christians in the arts.

The discrepancy is astounding. I have a bit of a theory about it. It's one of many possible reasons, so don't take it too seriously, but here it is:

Physics is the study of the natural world. If other physicists are anything like me, they look at the natural world, scratch their head, and say 'bloody hell, I'm never gonna understand this thing'. They are in constant awe. Anyone who knows anything about quantum theory knows that it's extremely weird, and incredibly impressive. The world doesn't behave the way you'd think, and the more physics you do, the more you find that out. But it is so difficult to understand, and such a marvel, that one can't help but marvel at the creator of it all, if one is so inclined as to believe there is a creator.

The Arts on the other hand, are humanistic (humanities). They're about what humans have done. When you study English literature you study Charles Dickens, and Virginia Wolf, and Margaret Atwood (my three favourites at the moment), and you marvel at people, and what they've done, and their enormous genius. How  could anyone read Oscar Wilde and think "Geez, if there's a god out there, I'm pretty impressed that he made Oscar Wilde". Sure they should think that, but instead they ditch the middle man, and just say "Geez, Oscar Wilde is pretty darn smart."

In this context I can imagine that there would be many more Christian physicists than Christian Arts people, and that is certainly the case.

But there's a bit of a worrying thing going on in physics, and at the moment I'm right in the thick of it. I'm studying two-dimensional physics, and some of the amazing things that come out of two-dimensional worlds (and they are amazing, believe me). But in case you haven't noticed, the world is 3D!

So is my research esoteric and useless? No. We can create 2D universes, and do physics with them. We can create 1D universes too. No worries!

And so now, while I still marvel at the maths, and while these properties are technically still part of nature, they're not natural, they're man-made. So when I do some physics on a 2D system, that system must be human-made. This worries me a little that physicists will become increasingly humanistic as well, and start worshipping the created like everyone else does...

Saturday, June 12, 2010

Differentiability

This is going to be a tad high faluting depending on your background, and for that I apologise. I think this issue is pretty important though.

The big bang:

I know a lot of people don't think the big bang happened, but let me tell you now, it did : )

Now that we've established that. I recently saw an interview with an extremely eminent philosopher. I don't know if he is a Christian or not. But he was saying that a creator causing the big bang is a more 'elegant' origin of the universe than the multi-verse theory.

Quickly, here is my version of multiverse:

The vacuum of space has 'zero' energy (as I'm sure you're aware). So you would imagine that the vacuum doesn't do anything. But this is not true. Actually, the vacuum has an average energy of 'zero'. On a very tiny scale it actually fluctuates. This is in some ways what quantum mechanics is all about - fluctuations, uncertainty. So it fluctuates. So here or there the energy might be positive for a fraction of a second, and somewhere else it might be negative for a fraction of a second. But on average it's zero.

But if you have a big enough box, somewhere or other, sooner or later, you'll get a really big fluctuation. It's inevitable. And eventually, one of these fluctuations will be so huge, that the energy will spontaneously change to matter (think Einstein, E = mc^2. E is energy and m is matter. So energy and matter are the same thing).

So we have a massive fluctuation that turns into matter - we have a big bang.

But of course, it's unlikely that a universe as big as ours would be the only fluctuation. And so there are many universes of various sizes, and ours is the one we live in. Thus there are multi-verses.

Ok, back to the eminent philosopher. He argues that the creator originated big-bang is more elegant than multiverse. I've heard at least one preacher quote this as well - an extremely good preacher who I have immense respect for. But I think this is wrong. Firstly elegance is difficult to define. Secondly I don't feel like it's very satisafactory. And thirdly, multiverse fits my idea of elegance much more precisely.

Think about it. The key ingredients in big bang are space, the laws of physics, and an anomalous BANG. The key ingredients of multiverse are just space and physics. No anomalies needed. It's self consistent. I find that to be more elegant.

But then where is the need for God? Well here's the main point of my post:

God created a differentiable manifold.

Not sure what a manifold is? It's nothing. Literally. It's a mathematical construct. But it's still there - here there and everywhere in fact. And it doesn't need to be there.

God made the world continuous. He made at least three dimensions - up, forwards and left (and there's actually at least one more). He made time. This thing we call space is ridiculously clever, and by no means a necessary property of existence.

So whatever you believe in: Creation Science (please don't), or Big Bang, or Multiverse, or whatever. If anyone takes issue with your theism, instead of arguing that point, I feel like you might as well just go back one step. Go even more fundamental. Who created dimensionality? Who created continuity of space-time (differentiability)? Why is there up, down, left, and at least one more. Why does time go forwards and not backwards? There are fundamental properties that determine the nature of our existence which are by no means innate to existence.